Teaching Technical Editing Today

A Case Study of Course Evolution and Pedagogical Challenges

Authors

  • Kelly Scarff Virginia Tech
  • Carolyn Commer Virginia Tech

Keywords:

technical editing, editing & publishing, technical communication pedagogy

Abstract

This article presents a case study of the evolution and pedagogical challenges of teaching an upper-level undergraduate Technical Editing and Style course at a research-intensive university in the southeastern United States. Drawing on interviews with six instructors across ranks—from graduate students to instructors to tenured faculty—we explore how the course has changed over time in terms of textbooks, industry alignment, and technology integration. Our findings reveal that while the course structure has remained largely consistent since its creation, instructors have adapted materials and assignments to reflect shifts in editing practices in various ways and often note the course as being one of the most rewarding to teach, citing its impact on students’ professional development and rhetorical awareness. We then identify five key pedagogical challenges and advocate for greater support and resources for instructors, especially as editing pedagogy must now address the implications of AI and evolving workplace demands. This study contributes to broader conversations about the future of Editing and Publishing (E&P) programs and underscores the enduring value of technical editing instruction in a rapidly changing communication landscape.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

Kelly Scarff, Virginia Tech

Kelly Scarff is Collegiate Assistant Professor and Technical Communication Program Director in the Department of Mechanical Engineering at Virginia Tech where she teaches courses in technical communication. She holds a PhD in Rhetoric and Writing from Virginia Tech and conducts research within environmental rhetoric, genre studies, and STEM communication. Her work has been published in Environmental Communication and Energy Research & Social Science. She is the author of Beyond Consensus: How Everyday Citizens Advocate for Local Environmental Issues, forthcoming from Lexington Books.

Carolyn Commer, Virginia Tech

Carolyn Commer is Associate Professor of English at Virginia Tech, where she serves as the Director of the Rhetoric and Writing PhD program and teaches courses in the Technical and Scientific Communication program. Technical Editing and Style is one of her favorite courses to teach. Her work on rhetorical pedagogy has been published in Argumentation and Advocacy, Literacy in Composition StudiesComposition StudiesRhetoric Review, Journal for the History of Rhetoric, and the volume Teaching Demagoguery and Democracy: Rhetorical Pedagogy in Polarized Times. She is the author of Championing a Public Good: A Call to Advocate for Higher Education (Penn State University Press, 2024).

Downloads

Published

2025-12-29

How to Cite

Scarff, K., & Commer, C. (2025). Teaching Technical Editing Today: A Case Study of Course Evolution and Pedagogical Challenges . Programmatic Perspectives, 16(2). Retrieved from https://programmaticperspectives.cptsc.org/index.php/jpp/article/view/135